PingalaPingalaOpen app

Which error is made when an independent samples t-test is used to compare the same patients before and after treatment?

Free Applied Statistics in Healthcare practice question on Parametric tests for comparing groups for BSN and Post-RN nursing students. Choose your answer, then open the answer and the explanation.

  1. ATreating paired observations as if they came from two separate groups
  2. BFailing to rank the data before computing the test statistic
  3. CApplying a continuity correction to a small sample of two groups
  4. DUsing a pooled variance estimate when the two group sizes are unequal
Show answer and explanation

✓ Correct answer A. Treating paired observations as if they came from two separate groups

Explanation

The independent samples t-test compares two separate groups of different people, so each person appears in only one group. When the same people are measured twice, the two sets of values are linked, and this pairing carries information that must be kept. Analysing such repeated measurements as though they came from unrelated groups ignores that link and gives a misleading result.

Why each option is right or wrong

  • ✓A. Treating paired observations as if they came from two separate groups — Repeated measurements on the same people are dependent, so they belong in a paired analysis rather than a two-group comparison.
  • ✗B. Failing to rank the data before computing the test statistic — Ranking the data is what non-parametric tests such as the Mann-Whitney U test do, not the independent samples t-test.
  • ✗C. Applying a continuity correction to a small sample of two groups — A continuity correction belongs to chi-square testing and has no place in the independent samples t-test.
  • ✗D. Using a pooled variance estimate when the two group sizes are unequal — A pooled variance estimate is a normal part of the independent samples t-test and is not an error, even with unequal group sizes.
TestGroups comparedData type
Independent samples t-testTwo separate groupsContinuous, normal
Paired t-testSame subjects measured twiceContinuous, normal
Mann-Whitney U testTwo separate groupsOrdinal or non-normal
EXAM HINT Independent = different people; Paired = same people twice.
اردو وضاحت
پیرڈ (paired) اور انڈیپنڈنٹ (independent) ڈیٹا میں کیا فرق ہے؟
جب ایک ہی مریض کا دو بار مشاہدہ کیا جائے، مثلاً علاج سے پہلے اور بعد میں، تو یہ (paired) ڈیٹا کہلاتا ہے کیونکہ دونوں ریڈنگز ایک ہی شخص سے جڑی ہوتی ہیں۔ اس کے برعکس (independent) ڈیٹا میں دو الگ الگ گروپس کے لوگ ہوتے ہیں اور ہر شخص صرف ایک گروپ میں آتا ہے۔ اس لیے ٹیسٹ چننے سے پہلے یہ دیکھنا ضروری ہے کہ ڈیٹا جڑا ہوا ہے یا الگ الگ لوگوں کا ہے۔
بار بار کی ریڈنگز کو الگ گروپس سمجھ لینے میں کیا غلطی ہوتی ہے؟
اصل غلطی یہ ہے کہ ایک ہی مریضوں کی پہلے اور بعد والی ریڈنگز کو دو الگ الگ گروپس کی طرح (independent samples t-test) سے پرکھا جائے۔ جب ایک ہی شخص کی دو ریڈنگز ہوں تو ان کے درمیان ایک تعلق ہوتا ہے اور یہی تعلق اہم معلومات رکھتا ہے، جسے (paired t-test) سنبھال کر رکھتا ہے۔ الگ گروپس سمجھ کر تجزیہ کرنے سے یہ تعلق نظر انداز ہو جاتا ہے اور نتیجہ گمراہ کن آ سکتا ہے۔

Key terms

  • pooled variance — A combined estimate of spread that merges the variability of two groups into one figure. ((pooled variance) do groups ke phelao (spread) ko mila kar banaya gaya ek mushtarak andaza.)

✓ Checked by Pingala Judge · Updated 15 Nov 2026

Practise 10 more Applied Statistics in Healthcare questions free →

Adaptive MCQs with explanations in English and Urdu, for BSN and Post-RN nursing students.

More Applied Statistics in Healthcare MCQs

All Applied Statistics in Healthcare MCQs · All subjects