A Wilcoxon signed rank test comparing paired pre- and post-intervention scores reports W = 18 with p = 0.03 at α = 0.05. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
Free Applied Statistics in Healthcare practice question on Non-parametric tests and chi-square for BSN and Post-RN nursing students. Choose your answer, then open the answer and the explanation.
AThe median difference between the paired scores is statistically significant.
BThe mean difference between the paired scores is statistically significant.
CThe two independent groups differ significantly in their median scores.
DThe test result is invalid because the sample was small.
Show answer and explanation
✓ Correct answerA. The median difference between the paired scores is statistically significant.
Explanation
The Wilcoxon signed rank test is a non-parametric test for paired (matched) data. It ranks the sizes of the differences within each pair and tests whether the median of those differences is zero, so a small p value means the paired differences are unlikely to be due to chance. Because it works on ranks rather than raw values, it is the median, not the mean, that the test addresses.
Why each option is right or wrong
✓A. The median difference between the paired scores is statistically significant. — A p value below the alpha level shows the ranked paired differences are unlikely by chance, so the median difference is significant.
✗B. The mean difference between the paired scores is statistically significant. — The test works on ranks of paired differences, so it addresses the median rather than the mean of those differences.
✗C. The two independent groups differ significantly in their median scores. — It compares paired scores within the same subjects, not two separate independent groups.
✗D. The test result is invalid because the sample was small. — Small samples can be analysed with this test; significance depends on the p value, not on sample size alone.
Feature
Wilcoxon signed rank test
Mann-Whitney U test
Data type
Paired / matched scores
Two independent groups
What it compares
Median of paired differences
Distribution of two groups
Basis of calculation
Ranks of within-pair differences
Ranks of all pooled values
Typical use
Pre- and post-intervention scores
Two separate treatment groups
EXAM HINT Signed rank = same person twice: sign shows direction, rank shows size of each paired difference.
اردو وضاحت
Wilcoxon signed rank test کیا ہے؟
یہ ایک non-parametric test ہے جو اُس وقت لگایا جاتا ہے جب ایک ہی مریض یا ایک ہی جوڑے کے دو readings آپس میں compare کرنے ہوں، مثلاً دوا سے پہلے اور بعد کی score۔ یہ data کے اصل numbers کی بجائے اُن کے ranks پر کام کرتا ہے، اِس لیے یہ median کے بارے میں بتاتا ہے۔
p = 0.03 آنے پر کیا نتیجہ نکالنا چاہیے؟
جب p value alpha 0.05 سے کم ہو تو مطلب یہ ہے کہ paired scores کے درمیان فرق اتفاقیہ نہیں بلکہ واقعی اہم ہے، اور یہ فرق median میں شمار ہوتا ہے۔ یہ test ایک ہی گروپ کے before اور after scores کا موازنہ کرتا ہے، اِس لیے دو الگ الگ گروپs والی بات یہاں لاگو نہیں ہوتی۔